Hello everyone and welcome back to another blog post. The indie game scene is filled with hidden gems—innovative, emotionally gripping, and artistically unique experiences that leave players craving more. Yet, despite their brilliance, some of these masterpieces never receive the sequels they deserve.
In this post, we’ll highlight 10 Indie Games That Deserve a Sequel But, for one reason or another, never did. Whether due to studio closures, financial constraints, or simply bad luck, these games left us wanting more.
1. Bastion (A Supergiant Classic That Needs a Proper Follow-Up)
(Supergiant Games, 2011)
Before Hades took the world by storm, Supergiant Games created Bastion—a groundbreaking action-RPG with a dynamic narrator, stunning hand-painted visuals, and an unforgettable soundtrack. Despite its critical success, Supergiant moved on to new projects (Transistor, Pyre, Hades), leaving Bastion as a standalone masterpiece.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The world of Bastion is rich with lore, and its narrator-driven storytelling could be expanded in new, exciting ways.
2. Ori and the Blind Forest (A Perfect Duology, But We Want More!)
(Moon Studios, 2015)
Ori and the Will of the Wisps (2020) was a beautiful conclusion to the series, but Moon Studios has moved on to new projects. The breathtaking visuals, emotional storytelling, and fluid platforming make Ori one of the best Metroidvanias ever—and we’d love to see another adventure in this universe.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The world of Niwen is too enchanting to leave behind.
3. A Hat in Time (A Charming 3D Platformer Left Hanging)
(Gears for Breakfast, 2017)
If there’s an Indie Game That Deserve a Sequel is A Hat in Time. This adorable collectathon captured the spirit of classic Mario and Banjo-Kazooie games, with quirky characters and inventive levels. Despite DLC expansions, a full sequel never materialized.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The game’s humor and creativity could fuel another fantastic adventure.
4. Hyper Light Drifter (A Stunning World Begging for More)
(Heart Machine, 2016)
With its cryptic storytelling, gorgeous pixel art, and intense combat, Hyper Light Drifter was a masterpiece. While Heart Machine moved on to Solar Ash, fans still hope for a return to this hauntingly beautiful world.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The lore is deep, and the gameplay mechanics could evolve further.
5. Outer Wilds (A One-of-a-Kind Experience That Can’t Be Replicated… But Should Be!)
(Mobius Digital, 2019)
Outer Wilds is a once-in-a-lifetime experience—but that doesn’t mean we wouldn’t love another spacefaring mystery with the same sense of wonder.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The core gameplay loop is so unique that a spiritual successor could work wonders.
6. Celeste (Madeline’s Story Is Over, But the Gameplay Could Continue)
(Extremely OK Games, 2018)
Celeste told a complete, emotional story, but its tight platforming mechanics and level design could easily support a sequel—perhaps with a new protagonist.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The movement mechanics are too perfect not to revisit.
7. Undertale (Toby Fox Moved On, But the Fanbase Hasn’t)
(Toby Fox, 2015)
Deltarune is its own thing, and Toby Fox has stated Undertale is complete. Yet, the world’s characters and humor are so beloved that fans would welcome another installment.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The underground still has untold stories.
8. The Messenger (A Brilliant Ninja Adventure That Ended Too Soon)
(Sabotage Studio, 2018)
This retro-inspired action-platformer had a killer twist and sharp writing. Sabotage moved on to Sea of Stars, but The Messenger’s universe could easily expand.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The time-shifting mechanics and lore have untapped potential.
9. Furi (A Stylish, High-Octane Boss Rush That Needs More)
(The Game Bakers, 2016)
This ultra-challenging action game featured incredible boss fights and a synthwave aesthetic. A sequel could introduce new combatants and deeper lore.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The combat system is too good for just one game.
10. Lisa: The Painful (A Brutal, Emotional RPG That Left Us Wanting Closure)
(Dingaling Productions, 2014)
This dark, post-apocalyptic RPG was emotionally devastating—and its ambiguous ending left room for more. A direct sequel could explore Buddy’s fate.
Why It Needs a Sequel: The world is too rich to abandon.
Final Thoughts: Why Don’t These Indies Get Sequels?
Indie developers often move on to new projects due to:
- Limited budgets (sequels are risky)
- Creative burnout (wanting to try something new)
- Studio closures (financial struggles)
Yet, the demand is there. Crowdfunding, publisher backing, or even spiritual successors could revive these beloved worlds. These are the Indie Games That Deserve a Sequel (But Never Got One)If you want to check some of these titles, check out the Steam store here.
Nice content! Love it